Check prices for these dates
Our top choices for Penn Yan 5-star hotels
1. 16 Elm Heritage Hotel
16 Elm Heritage Hotel5.0 star property
Downtown Trumansburg
9.6 out of 10, Exceptional, (106 reviews)
9.6/10
Exceptional
(106 reviews)
"A lovely, quiet, well-maintained boutique hotel in a quiet setting. A pleasant main street of a few shops and restaurants just a block away. We especially enjoyed breakfasts at a local market. The hotel is well placed for enjoying the Finger Lakes area and is fairly close to both Ithaca and Watkins Glen."
"A lovely, quiet, well-maintained boutique hotel in a quiet setting. A pleasant main street of a few shops and restaurants just a block away. We especially enjoyed breakfasts at a local market. The hotel is well placed for enjoying the Finger Lakes area and is fairly close to both Ithaca and Watkins Glen."
Karen
Top Penn Yan Hotel Reviews
The Benjamin Hotel
The Benjamin HotelWatkins Glen
10/10 Excellent
The room and bathroom were huge, clean and nicely decorated. It was nice having dedicated parking too. We didn’t realize that since it was end of their season, many spots were closed or only open certain days. Otherwise, we really enjoyed our stay at the Benjamin!
The room and bathroom were huge, clean and nicely decorated. It was nice having dedicated parking too. We didn’t realize that since it was end of their season, many spots were closed or only open certain days. Otherwise, we really enjoyed our stay at the Benjamin!
catherine
Canandaigua Guesthouse
Canandaigua GuesthouseCanandaigua
10/10 Excellent
The house is beautiful. The hosts, Valerie and Jason, were very friendly. Our room was comfortable and spacious. We will be back!
The house is beautiful. The hosts, Valerie and Jason, were very friendly. Our room was comfortable and spacious. We will be back!
Christine
Los Gatos Bed & Breakfast
Los Gatos Bed & BreakfastPenn Yan
10/10 Excellent
Our hosts, Charlie and Rebecca, were very gracious and gave us pointers for dinner locations. The room was very cosy and the breakfast scrumptious. Their coffee brand is worth trying even if you are not a coffee drinker
Our hosts, Charlie and Rebecca, were very gracious and gave us pointers for dinner locations. The room was very cosy and the breakfast scrumptious. Their coffee brand is worth trying even if you are not a coffee drinker
Nitin
Inns of Aurora Resort & Spa
Inns of Aurora Resort & SpaAurora
10/10 Excellent
The location, of course, makes it a standout, as well as the attention to detail. The decor is thoughtful--beautiful and welcoming. Anna and Renee were warm and attentive innkeepers. And COVID regulations were very good. I stayed in room #9, which was fully outfitted in Mackenzie Child. It had a lake view and was quite cozy and comfortable. I would like to return in a warmer season to better experience the lake. If I had to name one negative, it's that the water pressure was pretty weak in the...
The location, of course, makes it a standout, as well as the attention to detail. The decor is thoughtful--beautiful and welcoming. Anna and Renee were warm and attentive innkeepers. And COVID regulations were very good. I stayed in room #9, which was fully outfitted in Mackenzie Child. It had a lake view and was quite cozy and comfortable. I would like to return in a warmer season to better experience the lake. If I had to name one negative, it's that the water pressure was pretty weak in the...
Maria
Sutherland House Victorian Bed & Breakfast
Sutherland House Victorian Bed & BreakfastCanandaigua
10/10 Excellent
Wonderful experience and terrific breakfast!
Wonderful experience and terrific breakfast!
Brent
The Yorkshire Inn
The Yorkshire InnPhelps
10/10 Excellent
Yorkshire was a excellent bed and breakfast. Hosts are amazing. House was well appointed and clean. Breakfast was amazing. Definitely going to stay again in future. Luna was also a great host (dog) if your in the finger lakes region (Phelps NY) you won’t be disappointed 😁
Yorkshire was a excellent bed and breakfast. Hosts are amazing. House was well appointed and clean. Breakfast was amazing. Definitely going to stay again in future. Luna was also a great host (dog) if your in the finger lakes region (Phelps NY) you won’t be disappointed 😁
Jason
Chalet of Canandaigua
Chalet of CanandaiguaCanandaigua
10/10 Excellent
Quiet, clean, comfortable, and very helpful staff! Also the best breakfast. Thanks for a wonderful stay ❤️
Quiet, clean, comfortable, and very helpful staff! Also the best breakfast. Thanks for a wonderful stay ❤️
Jennifer
The Inn at Glenora Wine Cellars
The Inn at Glenora Wine CellarsDundee
10/10 Excellent
This was located in the heart of the Wine Trail on Seneca Lake. Beautiful views - quiet and comfortable. Will be coming back to stay here for sure!
This was located in the heart of the Wine Trail on Seneca Lake. Beautiful views - quiet and comfortable. Will be coming back to stay here for sure!
Deborah
The Mansion at Keuka Lake
The Mansion at Keuka LakeKeuka Park
10/10 Excellent
We had a lovely stay!
We had a lovely stay!
Linda
Inn at Taughannock Falls
Inn at Taughannock FallsTrumansburg
10/10 Excellent
Very beautiful
Very beautiful
Brian
Lakeside Resort
Lakeside ResortWatkins Glen
10/10 Excellent
The property was beautiful. We loved the chalet that we stayed in, super comfy bed, beautiful views, no matter which one you stay in. Staff was very kind, helping us park our trailer, and being accommodating. Would highly recommend this little secret in Watkins Glen.
The property was beautiful. We loved the chalet that we stayed in, super comfy bed, beautiful views, no matter which one you stay in. Staff was very kind, helping us park our trailer, and being accommodating. Would highly recommend this little secret in Watkins Glen.
Jillian
Hampton Inn Penn Yan
Hampton Inn Penn YanPenn Yan
10/10 Excellent
Beautiful by the lake. Pay the extra 10 or 20 dollars for the lake view rooms. Nice pool. Nice hot tub. Nice view. Nice deck. Nice gym. Nice people.
Beautiful by the lake. Pay the extra 10 or 20 dollars for the lake view rooms. Nice pool. Nice hot tub. Nice view. Nice deck. Nice gym. Nice people.
Vincenzo
Gothic Eves Inn and Spa Bed and Breakfast
Gothic Eves Inn and Spa Bed and BreakfastDowntown Trumansburg
10/10 Excellent
Michelle the innkeeper took good care of us when we visited the area. Great breakfasts! Nice location near the wineries, waterfalls and to visit Cornell University.
Michelle the innkeeper took good care of us when we visited the area. Great breakfasts! Nice location near the wineries, waterfalls and to visit Cornell University.
Bradley
B&B at Oliver Phelps
B&B at Oliver PhelpsCanandaigua
10/10 Excellent
This was a short stay at a Bed and Breakfast. We arrived in the pm, I did a bicycle ride while my wife shopped. We checked in around 5 and left the next morning around 10:00. It was a great B&B. Run by a husband and wife. Great breakfast with locally grown foods. We just didn't have enough time to really enjoy the stay. Hope to go back some day and spend more time there. If you are there in the fall watch where you park or the falling walnuts could cause dents.
This was a short stay at a Bed and Breakfast. We arrived in the pm, I did a bicycle ride while my wife shopped. We checked in around 5 and left the next morning around 10:00. It was a great B&B. Run by a husband and wife. Great breakfast with locally grown foods. We just didn't have enough time to really enjoy the stay. Hope to go back some day and spend more time there. If you are there in the fall watch where you park or the falling walnuts could cause dents.
John
Best Western Plus The Hammondsport Hotel
Best Western Plus The Hammondsport HotelHammondsport
10/10 Excellent
Very clean, modern hotel. Breakfast is so good, with many fresh baked pastries and breakfast pizza. There is also a brewery right next door, so that is a bonus! Highly recommend.
Very clean, modern hotel. Breakfast is so good, with many fresh baked pastries and breakfast pizza. There is also a brewery right next door, so that is a bonus! Highly recommend.
Michael
The Lake House on Canandaigua
The Lake House on CanandaiguaCanandaigua
10/10 Excellent
Every inch of this place is beautiful. And smells heavenly. Excellent food at both rose garden & the sand bar. Adorable s’mores kits for the kids with fires. We loved it!
Every inch of this place is beautiful. And smells heavenly. Excellent food at both rose garden & the sand bar. Adorable s’mores kits for the kids with fires. We loved it!
Amanda
The Naples Hotel
The Naples HotelNaples
10/10 Excellent
The hotel room was so cozy and it felt like having our own apartment. Tom was so cool to talk to and gave us the best recommendation for Halloween night! We had food from the restaurant and it was above and beyond our expectations. All of the businesses we went to encouraged visiting other businesses. An amazing stay. Even added on an extra night!
The hotel room was so cozy and it felt like having our own apartment. Tom was so cool to talk to and gave us the best recommendation for Halloween night! We had food from the restaurant and it was above and beyond our expectations. All of the businesses we went to encouraged visiting other businesses. An amazing stay. Even added on an extra night!
Holly
Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Geneva Finger Lakes
Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Geneva Finger LakesWestern Gardens
10/10 Excellent
Breakfast options were limited compared to other hotels I have stayed at. The coffee station needs to located in a bigger for multiple to use.
Breakfast options were limited compared to other hotels I have stayed at. The coffee station needs to located in a bigger for multiple to use.
Tyson
del Lago Resort & Casino
del Lago Resort & CasinoWaterloo
10/10 Excellent
Friendly staff and great places to eat inside
Friendly staff and great places to eat inside
Ann
Find out more about Penn Yan
There's nothing wrong with enjoying the finer things in life. Treat your every desire on your impending sabbatical. There's no reason to delay a getaway to Penn Yan any longer. You'll join the multitudes of vacationers who have made Penn Yan so fashionable recently. Besides that, you'll find that these hotels are kept in excellent condition and provide a fine place to lay your head at night. What are you waiting for? Reserve one of our 5-star hotels in Penn Yan and indulge in the finer things in life for a while.
5-Star Hotels in Penn Yan
Don't be afraid to demand the best service from your hotel, along with the best conditions. High-end restaurants, concierges, and pillow-fluffing are all at the ready. You're sure to find exactly the accommodation you need. We should also mention, the hotels in this area receive fantastic marks for customer satisfaction, so you know you'll be looked after during your getaway. What kind of amenities will make your stay a wonderful one? A full-body massage to help your cares fall away? A concierge to help you pick out your next adventure? Plush carpeting, piping hot coffees, and even space for your family pet in some cases...these hotels will leave you amazed.
Ready for experiences outside your hotel room? We've got you covered. From doing a bit of shopping to embracing the great outdoors, you'll never be bored on this retreat. No matter what's on your agenda, the 5-star hotels in Penn Yan are waiting for you to relax after a busy day. Ready to learn more? Read the review section and see what previous visitors have said. You're sure to find exactly what you're looking for!
Make Your Escape
The results are in, and Penn Yan 5-star hotels are the place to be when you book your next vacation. Additionally, these accommodations are highly rated -- 90% of visitors recommended 5-star hotels in Penn Yan! It's time to indulge yourself -- Expedia can help you land a great deal on accommodation. Pick out one of our Penn Yan 5-star hotels today and settle down in total tranquility when you're ready.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does it cost to stay in a 5-star hotel in Penn Yan?
There are many different pricing options for a 5-star hotel in Penn Yan on Expedia. The amount you pay will depend on when you want to travel, trip length and other factors. Compare all of the available properties for your preferred dates and make use of our pricing and other filters to lock in the ideal high-end stay.
- Search for the lowest price per night from $88
What makes a hotel 5 stars in Penn Yan?
From gourmet restaurants and 24/7 fitness centers to swimming pools and luxury bedding, the 5-star experience in Penn Yan is all about comfort and indulgence. But it takes more than just upscale perks to earn a 5-star rating. Stays must also offer remarkable services like in-room beauty treatments, on-site laundry and dry cleaning and 24-hour room service.
Are there any 5-star all-inclusive resorts in Penn Yan?
Use our handy filters to find an upscale getaway in Penn Yan where most of what you need is included. After your initial search, refine your results for resorts that have 5 stars and are deemed "All inclusive." The most important thing on the itinerary at these stays? Relaxation and indulgence.
Are there any 5-star vacation rentals in Penn Yan?
Although you won't find any 5-star vacation rentals in Penn Yan on our site, we have a range of retreats that promise a fantastic getaway. Find one that matches your style by checking out our vacation rentals in Penn Yan.