Find all hotels by Independent in Newcomb, NY from $109

"The room was spacious, parking was great, staff was friendly. No complaints, will likely stay again."

"The staff was very professional. They were very helpful and friendly. The room was very clean and it had a wonderful full view of the lake with a balcony."

"The room was very nice and i loved having a kitchen. I would definately stay here again."

"The bird cabins are the cutest thing. Very private and quiet. All staff and service has been so helpful. My husband and I have decided this is our weekend get away location from now on!!! The backyard playground is amazing and there was a beautiful wedding happening when we were here. Definitely a well rounded establishment!!! We will be back soon!!"

"Wonderful hotel & amazing amenities! We will certainly come back for another stay!"

"Indoor pool was too cold for kids. Very disappointing. The check in lady was great!"

"Room was nice, clean, and easy to get too with a great view of the lake! Great place. The dining room is lovely as well. Staff at checkin was great. "

"This is a motor inn, so stairs to second floor rooms. It was a very nice stay. The room was spacious and clean. The beds were comfortable and there was a big comfy recliner chair. Also small table for 2 with chairs. Big sliding glass doors opened to balcony with two chairs. Nice view of mountains in distance. There was some road noise when on balcony, but quiet when sliders closed. The lighting in room was excellent with recessed lights on dimmer switch in addition to lamps. Just coffee available for breakfast, but small fridge & microwave in room. Bathroom was larger than average & water pressure good. Would stay again."

"We liked location & quietness, especially since it’s a larger property. The Haystack Bar & Bistro had wonderful crunchy chicken wings, but my salad with added chicken was terrible, the chicken was chewy, not good. I didn’t eat. The server did offer me if I wanted something else, but the damage was already done. The salad was not removed from the bill or discounted. The modern rooms are designed well, with a huge lake wall art & unique lighting. Overall, a wonderful stay."