Find 3 Star Hotels in Sheldrake, NY from $133

"This property is very well managed and has great attention to detail from the food to the rooms and the grounds. The location is outstanding with great views a firepit, seating on the dock at the lake, etc. Will stay again 😊"

"The pool alone is reason to visit this stunning property. Old world opulence, beautiful views and grounds."

"Very relaxing, friendly staff and very clean and comfortable "

"Great place to stay, we will be going back!!!"

"Don't let the outside scare you. Restaurant and bar full of locals! "

"Cute little place was perfect for us. Owners were wonderful."

"Rooms are spacious, lovely, and comfortable. The owners are super friendly and helpful, and the breakfasts are delicious! Great place to stay for a get-away or for touring wine country; convenient to most the western Finger Lakes. Highly recommend."

"Stephanie was a great host and a great cook! Breakfast and the coffee was excellent! I would stay there again!"

"Absolutely beautiful property. Delicious breakfast and Shelley and Drew were fabulous hosts. I couldn’t recommend the benn conger inn enough. "

"Beautiful old home, very clean, owners Ashley and Dave were fantastic! "

"Nice view. Peaceful little place."

"This home leaves you speechless with its beautiful view of the lake. It is kid friendly and has lots of room for guest. The house is nicely furnished and newly renovated but still makes you feel at home! There were even snacks as a welcoming gift. I will definitely be coming back!"