Find all hotels by Preferred in Fire Island, NY from $231
Check prices for these dates
Compare rooms and suites by Preferred in Fire Island with rates, reviews, and availability. Most hotels are fully refundable.
The Garden City Hotel
Garden City
9.4 out of 10, Exceptional, (1014)
"Staff was very friendly. "
Maile
$207 nightly
The price is $231
Dec 7 - Dec 8
Total with taxes and fees
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in
Top Fire Island Hotel Reviews
Hyatt Regency Long Island
10/10 Excellent
Explore a world of travel with Expedia
- New York Hotels
- Ocean Bay Park Hotels
- Apartments in Ocean Bay Park
- Condo Rentals in Ocean Bay Park
- Vacation Homes in Ocean Bay Park
- Family Hotels in Ocean Bay Park
- Hotels with Restaurants in Ocean Bay Park
- Hotels with a Pool in Ocean Bay Park
- Cabin Rentals in Ocean Bay Park
- Motels in Ocean Bay Park
- Ocean Beach Hotels
- Romantic Hotels in Ocean Beach
- Cottages in Ocean Beach
- Vacation Homes in Ocean Beach
- Hotels with Hot Tubs in Ocean Beach
- Apartments in Ocean Beach
- Hotels with Free Breakfast in Ocean Beach
- Hotels with a Pool in Ocean Beach
- Oceanfront Hotels in Ocean Beach
- Family Hotels in Ocean Beach
- Beach Hotels in Ocean Beach
- Historic Hotels in Ocean Beach
- Hotels with Room Service in Ocean Beach
- Hotels with a View in Ocean Beach
- Hotels near Ocean Beach
- Hotels near Sunken Forest
- Dunewood Hotels
- Hotels near Atlantique Beach
- Hotels near Sailors' Haven
- Cherry Grove Hotels
- Hotels near Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre
- Apartments in Cherry Grove
- Condo Rentals in Cherry Grove
- Cabin Rentals in Cherry Grove
- Motels in Cherry Grove
- Cottages in Cherry Grove
- Kismet Hotels
- Condo Rentals in Kismet
- Motels in Kismet
- Vacation Homes in Kismet
- Aparthotels in Kismet
- 3 Star Hotels in Kismet
- Hotels near Lighthouse Beach
- Hotels near Great South Bay
- Hotels near Carrington House
- Hotels near Fire Island Lighthouse
- Fire Island Pines Hotels
- Pet-friendly Hotels in Fire Island Pines
- Villas in Fire Island Pines
- 5 Star Hotels in Fire Island Pines
- Guest Houses in Fire Island Pines
- Extended Stay Hotels in Fire Island Pines
- Hotels with a Pool in Fire Island Pines
- Hotels near Heckscher State Park
- Great River Hotels
- La Quinta Inn & Suites Hotels in East Islip
- West Sayville Hotels
- Visit Ocean Bay Park
- Ocean Bay Park Vacations
- Visit Ocean Beach
- Ocean Beach Vacations
- Where to stay in Ocean Beach
- Sunken Forest
- Atlantique Beach
- Sailors' Haven
- Visit Cherry Grove
- Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre
- Cherry Grove Vacations
- Visit Kismet
- Kismet Vacations
- Lighthouse Beach
- Great South Bay
- Carrington House
- Fire Island Lighthouse
- Visit Fire Island Pines
- Fire Island Pines Vacations
- Heckscher State Park
- Hertz Rental Cars in Ocean Beach
- Car rentals near Ocean Beach
- Car rentals near Atlantique
- Car rentals near Dunewood
- Car rentals near Fair Harbor
- Car rentals near Saltaire
- Car rentals near Cherry Grove
- Car rentals near Kismet
- Localiza Argentina Rental Cars in Fire Island Pines
- Mini Car Rentals in Fire Island Pines
- Thrifty Car Rental Rental Cars in Fire Island Pines
- Car rentals near Fire Island Pines
- Car rentals near Great River