The best area to stay in Suttons Bay is right in the village center, particularly along St. Joseph Street, which runs parallel to the bay.
This area is the heart of activity, with easy access to the waterfront, the village marina, and the main concentration of shops, art galleries, and restaurants. Many accommodations in this central strip offer views of Suttons Bay itself. It's a convenient base for exploring everything the village offers on foot.
Couples often find this central village area ideal. You can enjoy strolls along the bay, dine at local eateries, and browse unique shops without needing to drive. The proximity to the Leelanau Trail, a paved biking and walking path, also offers opportunities for outdoor activity together.
For travelers looking for a quieter experience with beautiful views, staying slightly north or south of the immediate village center, still along the bay, is a great option.