Find all hotels by Extended Stay America in Potter Lake, WI

"The place is very nice and good price. Things to do right in the hotel. Only complaint is the water was warm not hot for showers and it took a while to even get warm"

"Was disappointed in the final price. Much higher than expected. Staff was very pleasant. Could not get a table for dinner Thursday evening. Would have been nice if someone had suggested to get a reservation at the time we checked in as most local diners were closed that evening. The trolley ride to see holiday lights was c awesome. They took extra good care of my son, who was in a wheelchair. The pool is exceptional. Best in WI. "

"The room was very clean and the staff were fantastic. "

"It was a nice stay overall!"

"Beds were comfortable, bathrooms were clean, room was very clean. I wipe everything down when I get there and I got nothing but clean. Nothing showing on my Lysol wipes after wiping. Location to Brewer stadium and The Forum was about and 15 - 20 min commute but worth it due to location of this hotel in Brookfield. Felt safe all the time. Breakfast was good. Everything was warm and not overcooked. Cheese omelets and sausages was the hot portion. Had all the continental options as well. Definitely will stay there again!! Pool and hot tub looked nice but didn’t get to enjoy them. No time. "

"Container holding hot foods was not working, Cold eggs and sausage"

"Great property! We will be back!"

"The staff was very nice. The room was clean. Everything was a easy process "

"Clean room and both receptionists were friendly. "