Find Historic Hotels in Long Island

"An incredible trip with exceptional service and attention to detail. Wonderful staff , great food and superb cleanliness. "

"The property was absolutely gorgeous and the staff are so friendly and fun. The only change I would suggest is to have more staff available at the pool area for bar service. The bar was very close so we were able to get our own drinks but that would be my only suggestion. It was our first trip to Galley Bay but it will not be the last!"

"Great place to stay, we were visiting for four nights to watch the Cricket. We all agreed that four nights wasn’t enough and that we would happily come back again. "

"I loved that the resort was on the beach and what an amazing beach it is. Beautiful white sand and clear, calm water. The complimentary permanent beach shades/cabanas and lounge chairs were a welcome addition and made my trips to the beach such a pleasure!!"

"This is just what we were looking for during our anniversary trip! Calm, quiet, serene right on the beach. Beautiful views, friendly and helpful staff. Literally had the beach and pool completely to ourselves almost daily. The only thing that could be improved upon would be longer dinner hours and a few more food options for all-inclusive guests. 4.75/5 stars!"

"Peaceful and perfect! Plenty of space to have solitude if you wanted. Service was great and the setting was beautiful. Will definitely come back!"

"Excellent, beautiful resort! Super quiet and relaxing. Perfect for a honeymoon! Only negative was the sushi boat we ordered for our room -- do not waste your money on it. Only 9 pieces for over $100."

"The resort was exactly what I was looking for. Somewhere quiet and peaceful. The room was comfortable although the AC wasn't working properly at least the room was at a good temperature perfect for resting. Both the pool and the beach were beautiful, not crowded and clean. There was no loud music playing except by the pool bar which was fine because it was only for a few hours during the afternoon. The night was as peaceful and relaxing as you would want with just the sounds of nature. The only draw back was the lack of management for the restaurants. The first night it took well over an hour and a half to be served our meal. The remaining nights were better. The lack of attention to the tables for serving coffee, water or drinks needs better training. Also the mosquitos and flies can be a bit overwhelming during the dusk hours for outside dinning. Also I do wish they had water for the guest rooms as well. Overall the resort is nice could absolutely use some updating. But all in all I enjoyed my stay and would recommend. If you are looking for a quiet, budgeted all inclusive resort then this is the place to go."

"The staff at the resort are friendly and provide helpful information about the area. We were there during the off-season and there are plenty of things to do. We were happy to have a room with a kitchen to cook on nights we were not interested in going out. The room is 3 times the size of an average hotel room. The view is amazing and there is always a taxi available to explore the island. The marina has a few restaurants in the area and the supermarket is within walking distance. The massage was a big treat for us. We will definitely return."