Our first and hopefully not our last stay at the Come As You Are Inn was a wonderful experience. Mark and Ari provide a welcoming and accomodating space within which one feels at home . The accomodations are delightful . The breakfasts , including freshly baked goodies are just right to start the day. Topping it all off , we enjoyed the opportunity to engage in extended conversations with Mark and Ari exploring a myriad of topics. A rarity in todays world. If you are looking for something more...
Our first and hopefully not our last stay at the Come As You Are Inn was a wonderful experience. Mark and Ari provide a welcoming and accomodating space within which one feels at home . The accomodations are delightful . The breakfasts , including freshly baked goodies are just right to start the day. Topping it all off , we enjoyed the opportunity to engage in extended conversations with Mark and Ari exploring a myriad of topics. A rarity in todays world. If you are looking for something more...
First time we had stayed at this facility. Front desk staff was outstanding and took action to make us feel very welcome. Maid service could have been better since they only came in 2 of the four days that we were guests. Had to ask the front desk for a replacement for the tissue box.
Front desk folks (Irene Reyes especially) went out of their way to make us feel welcome and secure a wheelchair for my wife during the entire stay.
Thought the pricing was a little steep but it was...
First time we had stayed at this facility. Front desk staff was outstanding and took action to make us feel very welcome. Maid service could have been better since they only came in 2 of the four days that we were guests. Had to ask the front desk for a replacement for the tissue box.
Front desk folks (Irene Reyes especially) went out of their way to make us feel welcome and secure a wheelchair for my wife during the entire stay.
Thought the pricing was a little steep but it was...
Gorgeous gorgeous hotel!! And the absolute nicest staff I have ever encountered! The restaurant breakfast wasn’t that great but everything else was 11/10!!
Gorgeous gorgeous hotel!! And the absolute nicest staff I have ever encountered! The restaurant breakfast wasn’t that great but everything else was 11/10!!
Such a beautiful property, lots of trees, lovely landscaping. They keep Crassula in pots on all of the porches as long as weather permits. The room I stayed in (double queen) was very spacious. Wood beamed ceiling with a ceiling fan, walk in shower. Loved the restaurant that was open for breakfast daily. Open for dinner Tuesday - Saturday while I was there. It's still family owned and run after 69 years. Great dining options all around, and lots to see and do on the island - although you...
Such a beautiful property, lots of trees, lovely landscaping. They keep Crassula in pots on all of the porches as long as weather permits. The room I stayed in (double queen) was very spacious. Wood beamed ceiling with a ceiling fan, walk in shower. Loved the restaurant that was open for breakfast daily. Open for dinner Tuesday - Saturday while I was there. It's still family owned and run after 69 years. Great dining options all around, and lots to see and do on the island - although you...
Immaculately clean and the most helpful staff. All of the staff that we interacted with during our 7 day stay were approachable, and friendly. And went out of their way to be helpful. It was refreshing to to see employees who genuinely cared about their guests comfort. All compliments were received with pride and appreciation.
Well done!
Immaculately clean and the most helpful staff. All of the staff that we interacted with during our 7 day stay were approachable, and friendly. And went out of their way to be helpful. It was refreshing to to see employees who genuinely cared about their guests comfort. All compliments were received with pride and appreciation.
Well done!
Bernadette
Reviewed November 9, 2026Reviewed November 9, 2026
Title: A Peaceful Getaway Worth Every Penny
I recently stayed at Aqua Beach Hotel suite and had an absolutely amazing experience. From the moment I arrived, I was impressed by the peaceful atmosphere—it truly felt like a hidden escape. The amenities were top-notch, and everything was clean, modern, and well-maintained.
Yes, the stay was on the pricier side, but honestly, it was worth every cent. The comfort, service, and ambiance more than made up for it. I only wish I had booked a longer...
Title: A Peaceful Getaway Worth Every Penny
I recently stayed at Aqua Beach Hotel suite and had an absolutely amazing experience. From the moment I arrived, I was impressed by the peaceful atmosphere—it truly felt like a hidden escape. The amenities were top-notch, and everything was clean, modern, and well-maintained.
Yes, the stay was on the pricier side, but honestly, it was worth every cent. The comfort, service, and ambiance more than made up for it. I only wish I had booked a longer...
Our stay was really nice. Beautiful, clean room. The breakfast at the barn in the morning was great. Helpful staff—I forgot my headphones in my room after checking out and they were kept safe for me till I was able to pick them up.
Our stay was really nice. Beautiful, clean room. The breakfast at the barn in the morning was great. Helpful staff—I forgot my headphones in my room after checking out and they were kept safe for me till I was able to pick them up.
We stayed at the Dansford because we were attending a bridal shower there. A unique hotel with a marina and a ferry coming next door, a lovely view. The staff was very friendly a helpful.
The Dansford has a lot of character. It is old but not at all rundown. Our room was on the third floor with no elevator so you might want to ask for a first floor room if that will be a problem.
We stayed at the Dansford because we were attending a bridal shower there. A unique hotel with a marina and a ferry coming next door, a lovely view. The staff was very friendly a helpful.
The Dansford has a lot of character. It is old but not at all rundown. Our room was on the third floor with no elevator so you might want to ask for a first floor room if that will be a problem.
Ready to experience the next standard in luxury? We know you're thinking about it. Pamper yourself on your impending break. There's no reason to delay a getaway to Fire Island any longer. You'll join the multitudes of vacationers who have made Fire Island so fashionable in the last year. You can also expect excellent customer service from these hotels, so get ready to kick back and indulge. You deserve an outstanding getaway. Our 5-star hotels in Fire Island are the perfect places to relax in during your next chunk of time off.
Book the Best Fire Island 5-Star Hotels
You'll have a wonderful time at one of these 5-star hotels. High-end restaurants, concierges, and in-room massages are all at the ready. You're sure to find exactly the accommodation you need. You'll also enjoy a high standard of care and meticulous guest relations, so get ready for a wonderful adventure. What kind of amenities will make your stay a wonderful one? A concierge to help you make reservations at that outstanding restaurant? A deep-tissue massage to help your cares fall away? High thread-count sheets, delectable chocolate desserts, and even a hot tub in the bathroom...these hotels will leave you amazed.
You won't sleep and order room service the entire time, though. We've got you covered. From doing a bit of shopping to embracing the great outdoors, you'll never be bored on this retreat. No matter what's on your agenda, the 5-star hotels in Fire Island are waiting for you to rest up after a busy day. Ready to learn more? Then check out our listings and pick the perfect accommodation for your needs.
Your Getaway Starts Today
The results are in, and Fire Island 5-star hotels are the place to be when you book your next vacation. If you've been dreaming about a vacation set here, then go ahead and book it. It's time to indulge yourself -- Expedia can help you land a great deal on accommodation. Choose one of our Fire Island 5-star hotels today and decompress in the lap of luxury at your convenience.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does it cost to stay in a 5-star hotel in Fire Island?
The amount you pay for a 5-star hotel in Fire Island depends on factors like when you want to go and the length of your trip. An insider tip for landing an awesome deal? Use our pricing filters to compare all of the available accommodations for your preferred dates.
Search for the lowest price per night from $93
What makes a hotel 5 stars in Fire Island?
Exceptional guest service characterizes every 5-star hotel in Fire Island. From the moment you arrive, staff cater to your every need, whether recommending activities or providing a turn-down service. On top of that, hotels must feature top-rate amenities to be entitled to a 5-star rating. These can include luxury bathrobes, spas or saunas, pools, gastronomic kitchens and knowledgeable concierge.
Are there any 5-star all-inclusive resorts in Fire Island?
Expedia's filter tool is the quickest way to find exactly what you want. Select "5-star" and "All inclusive" to see the most upscale hotels in Fire Island where your accommodations, meals, activities and entertainment are included in the upfront price. At these stays, your trip is pure relaxation and indulgence from the moment you enter the lobby.
Are there any 5-star vacation rentals in Fire Island?
Our site doesn't offer any 5-star vacation rentals in Fire Island. However, you can still find a few top-rated stays where the only thing on your agenda will be to relax and enjoy yourself. See what's available by browsing our vacation rentals in Fire Island.