Search Vacation Homes in Shelter Island Heights

"Wonderful home in a gorgeous area. The house was updated beautifully and clean, spacious deck and the pool was great. We really loved our time there and would stay again! Host was responsive and easy to work with as well :)"

"Lovely quaint home. Very clean and spacious. Perfect for a family getaway . Highly recommend."

"House was very nice. Location is great. Easy walk to beach and convenient to Westbrook center."

"We had a big group with all different ages. Everybody enjoyed their stay. The home was clean, comfortable, and very thoughtfully decorated. The pool table, poker table and Pac-Man kept us all entertained during out time there. Hosts were friendly and responsive."

"Condo was in a great location. Close to all. Well equipped and very comfortable! Excellent host!"

"Beautifully decorated comfortable and clean would definitely rent again"

"My family and I thoroughly enjoyed our time in Sag Harbor. The home was conveniently located and ideal for our five-day getaway. Daniel was quick to respond and offered excellent recommendations for restaurants and beach spots. The property was beautiful, and the pool provided a tranquil setting. We're eagerly anticipating future trips."

"We had a wonderful time. A beautiful home and an easy process from booking through check out."

"Awesome break away from reality. Hope to return soon!"

"Property was perfect. Very nicely updated and had everything we needed for a great beach getaway. Kevin was extremely responsive when we had questions. Would definitely stay again!"

"Beautiful home with separate space for everyone and close to water and town!"

"my family and i grew up coming to hampton bays - and while myself and my parents have moved away - a family wedding brought us back to the area and we were so happy to stay local in this perfect home. it felt great to be back in the old neighborhood and not have to be cramped at my brothers home just a short 5 minute drive away. i hope we can stay again during our next trip!"

"Comfortable house with a well stocked kitchen and convenient laundry. We enjoyed walking to the town and fish market. The train runs between the town and waterfront, entry points are at the far ends of town, at either end of the board walk. Nice quiet neighborhood."

"We stayed at this house for 3 days at the beginning of the season. It’s very close to everything in town and was very thoughtfully designed and maintained. It was absolutely perfect, especially the amazing garden. Highly recommended."

"House was very clean and host was exceptional. Very relaxing place to stay."

"This place exceeded all expectations, offering a perfect blend of convenience and serenity. Situated just moments from downtown, the location provided easy access to the vibrant community, while still offering a peaceful retreat. The highlight of our stay was undoubtedly the private beach access. Tucked away in a tranquil neighborhood, it boasted unparalleled beauty and tranquility. Simply being in the vicinity was a getaway in itself, with breathtaking views that soothed the soul. The...

"Lovely, well maintained property. Short walk to the shoreline and the neighborhood market (which has great coffee, muffins, shakes, etc). The fenced yard was wonderful for the dogs. Serene and quiet but friendly neighborhood. Excellent communication with property owner and easy check-in/out. Everything was as described on the site and it made for a wonderful weekend getaway!"

"This place was nice and roomy for our family of 8 plus 3 littles kiddos. Pretty clean as well. I gave listing accuracy a 5 because it is accurate but that may be because it doesn't tell you much. We were a little short on towels, many light bulbs were burnt out or just missing. We replaced some (they were there) and moved others to balance out the light. No kitchen linens, short on bath towels, short on paper towels and definitely not enough TP. 3 partial rolls and 1 bathroom had none so we had...

"It was a great weekend"