The Best Cheap Hotels in Sugarloaf Key in 2025

Check availability on Sugarloaf Key Cheap Hotels

Tonight

Tomorrow

Next weekend

In two weeks

Top Sugarloaf Key Cheap Hotels

Private beach, snorkeling, kayaking, motor boating

Sugarloaf Key Hotel at KOA Resort

Summerland Key

Pedro Miguel

View all properties

Find out more about Sugarloaf Key

Discover cheap things to do in Sugarloaf Key

Sugarloaf Key offers a wealth of affordable experiences for budget-conscious travelers, making it a perfect spot for families seeking adventure without breaking the bank. Start your explorations at the Sugarloaf Key Bat Tower, where you can marvel at the unique structure and learn about the local wildlife—it's free to visit! For a taste of the area's natural beauty, head to the nearby Sugarloaf Key State Park, where you can enjoy hiking trails or pack a picnic to savor while taking in the stunning views. Fishing enthusiasts can cast their lines off the nearby bridges for a chance to catch snapper or grouper, providing a fun and inexpensive family activity. If you're looking for a unique dining experience, visit the local food trucks that often serve fresh seafood and delicious key lime pie at reasonable prices. For accommodations, consider staying in the heart of Sugarloaf Key, where you can find charming, budget-friendly hotels with easy access to these attractions. Enjoy the laid-back island vibe while exploring the friendly community, ensuring your family feels both pampered and well taken care of during your stay.

Find the best cheap hotels in Sugarloaf Key

For travelers seeking budget-friendly accommodations in Sugarloaf Key, these two hotels offer excellent value without compromising on comfort and amenities.

Sugarloaf Key Hotel at KOA Resort

Why it's great for a budget-friendly vacation: The Sugarloaf Key Hotel at KOA Resort is a fantastic choice for budget-conscious travelers, an impressive guest review rating of 9.8. This hotel provides essential amenities like free WiFi and complimentary self-parking, ensuring guests have everything they need for a comfortable stay. With a range of outdoor activities nearby, guests can enjoy the beautiful Florida weather at the beach or enjoy onsite snorkeling and motorboating adventures.
Other amenities: In addition to budget-friendly features, guests can relax at the outdoor pool or unwind in the hot tub. The hotel includes a kitchenette in each room, complete with a microwave and stovetop, perfect for preparing meals. A sandy beach is just steps away, enhancing the vacation experience. Other highlights include evening entertainment, a marina for boat rentals, and access to kayaking and boat tours nearby, making it an ideal spot for adventures on the water.
Nearby attractions: Key West Naval Station - 3.92 miles, Upper Sugarloaf Sound - 0.89 miles, Upper Sugarloaf Key - 0.62 miles

Sugar Loaf Lodge

Why it's great for a budget-friendly vacation: Sugar Loaf Lodge offers budget-conscious travelers a cozy retreat with a solid review rating of 8.2. Guests appreciate the free WiFi and self-parking options, making it easy to enjoy a straightforward stay. With its waterfront location, the lodge provides a perfect base for outdoor enthusiasts looking to explore the nearby ocean activities.
Other amenities: The lodge features an outdoor pool for relaxation and tennis courts for some active fun. Guests can take advantage of daily housekeeping and enjoy the beautiful garden surroundings. For those interested in adventure, boat tours and kayaking offer exciting ways to experience the water. Each room comes with a balcony or patio, providing a great spot to unwind after a day of exploration.
Nearby attractions: Key West Naval Station - 0.65 miles, Upper Sugarloaf Sound - 0.13 miles, Lower Sugarloaf Sound - 0.6 miles

How can I get cheap hotels in Sugarloaf Key?

Best tips to find a cheap hotel in Sugarloaf Key

If you're looking to travel to Sugarloaf Key on a budget, you'll be happy to know that you can find hotels for as low as . Of course, that price is affected by amenities, star rating, and even the time of year you visit. At most, hotel prices can be as high as . Staying a short amount of time in Sugarloaf Key is an effective way to reduce hotel costs.
When you cut your vacation down to just a few days, you don't have to worry as much about hotel prices since you don't have that many nights to stay. For budget hotels in Sugarloaf Key, 3 to 4 days should be all the nights you need. That's generally enough to enjoy the city's top attractions, though there's certainly enough to do to warrant a week-long trip.
When booking cheap hotel rooms in Sugarloaf Key, it's typically best to book about 3 weeks in advance. Book further in advance than that and you could be paying too much for your room, as hotels will often overestimate future demand. However, if you wait too long, you might find that the hotel has been completely booked.
When you utilize search filters on Expedia, you'll be able to narrow down your results in a flash. These search filters cover a wide variety of factors you may be interested in when it comes to finding a cheap hotel in Sugarloaf Key, including amenities such as Free Breakfast, 2-star rating, or proximity to local attractions. You can even set filters for price limits to ensure that all the displayed results are within your budget.

Top Sugarloaf Key Hotel Reviews

Parrot Key Hotel & Villas

10/10 Excellent

"We had a wonderful time and enjoyed your facility tremendously. We will be telling everyone that we know are coming to the Keys to be sure and check you out. Need paper towels coffee bar—needs adequate table for eating and card games for any improvements. "