Nice hotel: clean and comfortable.
Posted Jan 15, 2017
We spent 4 nights at the Gatsby Hotel. Our room was comfortable, clean and updated. Anthony at the front desk was great - very helpful and pleasant. I have no complaints about our stay and I would definitely stay there again while visiting New York. I would however, make three suggestions to the hotel. While the room had a good heating system and I was not cold, I felt the bed could use heavier blankets. The weight of the blankets were equivalent to 2 sheets and a lightweight blanket. We were there in January and I like the feel of something heavier. The second suggestion is, if possible to adjust the heavy doors so that they do not slam as they are closing. If you were careful to hold the door, you could close it quietly but for the most part, I heard a lot of slamming doors. Part of the blame should definitely go to other guests who allowed their doors to slam behind them, often late night and early am. My final suggestion would be to add a few vending machines with drinks and snacks. All in all, we had a very pleasant stay and I would recommend your hotel to family and friends.