City Island Residences

"The location was great. It was close to everything. However, it can get crowded. The room was outdated and felt like a 2.5 star hotel. The staff was not friendly. The wait times were long, but this is New York so that wasn't entirely unexpected"

"Great location! Subway stops on each corner, close to attractions, shopping, and food. Rooms are SMALL! This is expected for NY and an older property however the first room they put my group of 4 travelers in was not suitable. We reserved an executive room which should have been their second largest room however it seems we were given a standard room. The bed was literally at the door with barely any room to walk. Thankfully, staff at the guest were able to help us and relocate us to the appropriate room. Did the new room smell? Yes. Was the door locking questionable? Yes. However, we made the best of our trip because we were there for a good time not a long time."

"I did not need parking. Location was awesome. "

"It feels very modernized and pleasant to be around."

"The room was clean, the bed was comfortable and the location was amazing!"

"I love the property, it was very beautiful and clean. The Resturant was amazing, rooms updated and nice and location amazing. Would definitely stay again. The only thing I didn’t like was the mandatory $35.00 per person entertainment fee. I feel it’s something you should know upfront not when you get there. Naquita Brown"

"Have stayed here for years. Haven’t though in a couple years and our room was worn out. It was 2-star at best. Too bad because great location. "

"Na"

"The hotel is well situated, and the staff were helpful. The property needs some updates internally and the lifts often didn’t work. At the time of our visit construction work was being done right outside the hotel all through the night and the noise heard in the hotel rooms on the road side was considerable. We requested a room move which the staff did accommodate. If staying at this hotel I would recommend requesting a room at the back, as these rooms are much quieter."