There were pros and cons with the Mayflower...I had to be in Queens NYC at 6am, it was very easy to find off rt.95 in Milford...I arrived at midnight, but no issues checking in, the front desk guy was cool, great sense of humor...had to pay $4 dep for the old school key, no biggie. Room was fine, very dated, but the bed was comfortable with an old-school comforter...pillows need an upgrade tho...bathroom was very clean, shower was good, nice heat and pressure was good...had a nice fridge and great A/C with a remote...TV was fine, but satellite channels were slow to respond...somw shady character urking about, but I didn't feel unsafe...easy checkout at 3:30am....So, for $80 I can't complain too much, but not sure if I'd book it again, it did give me a bit of a Twin Peaks vibe to be honest....all n all it was OK for a last minute stay.
Reviewed on May 9, 2026