Search Cassadaga Cottages

"Great beach, our dog loved it. Will have to come back when its warm."

"Beautiful well kept cottage on the lake! Great location to restaurants and shops. The cottage had everything you needed!"

"Thanks David and Barbara! Again, the accommodations were amazing, and the views and sunsets were beautiful as always! Can't wait to stay again! Thank you Jesse and Jenn."

"I think I have stayed at either this cabin or the other one 4 to 5 times now. I love it here and the cabins are amazing. My girlfriends absolutely loved it and now they want to come back! I know I will definitely be back!"

"The house is exactly as advertised. The house is very clean, nicely furnished and comfortable. The kitchen is well apppointed with everything you need. The beds are comfortable. Very nice amenties throughout. Neighborhood was quiet (although this was April and not peak lake season). The neighbors are great. Large yard. A bit soggy duet to rain and mud management was a constant. Jason was awesome - excellent communications and very prompt on replies. If we get back to Lakewood, we would stay...

"The property was beautiful and very warming! The property manager was extremely polite and helpful with any questions or issues. Overall my kids couldnt have had a better time being at the property and loved sitting on the inlet watching the ducks, beavers and geese every evening! Definitely recommend staying here if your traveling near Mayville."

"A very pleasant and quiet property on the lake. "

"Stayed here for the eclipse but got much more out of it. It was a nice quiet stay right on the lake which made for and enjoyable long weekend. Havinging th abilty to walk out, sit around a fire on a lake and fish was quite enjoyable. The tiny home was perfect for our needs and look forward to staying here again in the future. It was pet friendy yet lacked any animal hair which was a big concern as we had more than 1 person alerigic to dogs but had to bering out non shedding dog with us. Overall...

"Very comfortable and relaxing. Could see and hear the lake from the hot tub. Very nice."

"Very nice and everything was just as advertised on Vrbo. Very clean and everything needed was provided. Owner was very helpful and responsive. Will definitely stay again."

"Excellent property, location, and host. Rachel was very friendly and responsive. Thank you!"

"What a lovely lakeside location! We especially enjoyed watching the wildlife and had a truly restful time in Chautauqua."

"We had a wonderful visit at this tiny house on the lake. Beautiful views. The house itself was open and spacious. Ended up we had a few tag alongs and it easily accommodated 6 adults. We will be back again! PS: You can fish from the beach."

"We had a great stay! The house is nicely updated and comfortable. We didn’t plan to do a lot on this trip and stayed in the whole time. The house provided everything we needed for our stay. We would stay here again!"

"This property had plenty of room for our family. Although the main portion of the house is not air conditioned, the bedrooms all had room air conditioners. We really enjoyed being right on the lake. The property between the house and the lake isn't big, but it's very nicely shaded and we spent a lot of time out there. The kids loved the fishing. The cleanliness of the property was an issue. Carpets had crumbs and were dirty. Bathroom wasn't cleaned well. The house clearly had not been dusted...

"The property and cottage are really good. Host Dan Clark is awesome"

"Cottage was exactly as advertised. Quiet cozy dead end street great for walking the dog. Also very nice outdoor area with fenced in yard and gas grill."

"I've stayed at many VRBOs over the years but Blue Oar has really set the bar high for me from now on. Firstly, the location setting was perfect. A quiet street with gorgeous lake views that can be enjoyed from the large front porch with comfy seating to include a relaxing porch swing. There is plenty of parking. And lots of outside space as well, not only there at the house, but at the private beach area that has a cool firepit and a dock with seating. When we were there it was too early in the...

"Very comfortable cottage with a great view of the lake. Cold weather prevented full enjoyment of the outside deck, but enclosed porch and well-thought out interior still made this an excellent choice without being weather-dependent. Perfect spot to rest and recharge - I look forward to returning!"

"The house and grounds are absolutely beautiful. The setting is rural and quiet, and the large deck on the back of the house is a wonderful gathering space for family and friends. The kitchen was well appointed with everything that we needed, and the decor throughout the house was pleasing."