Find beach hotels in Shelter Island, NY

Shelter Island and its attractions for beach lovers

Shelter Island, New York, is a hidden gem for beach-loving travelers seeking a serene escape. Start your adventure at Crescent Beach, where soft sand meets gentle waves, perfect for families to enjoy a day of sun and surf. Just a bike ride away, you can explore the picturesque Mashomack Preserve, offering scenic trails and the chance to spot local wildlife. For a delightful afternoon, visit the charming Sunset Beach, known for its stunning sunsets and vibrant beach bar scene, where you can indulge in fresh seafood while enjoying the ocean breeze. If you're in the mood for some history, the Shelter Island Historical Society provides fascinating insights into the island's rich past amid its beautiful gardens. Lastly, don’t miss a visit to the local art galleries, which showcase unique pieces inspired by the surrounding landscapes. For accommodations, consider staying near Crescent Beach, where luxurious hotels like the Shelter Island House offer modern amenities and attentive service, ensuring your family feels pampered while being just steps away from the beach. The combination of relaxation and exploration makes this area an unforgettable choice for your beach getaway.

Find the best beach hotels and resorts in Shelter Island

For those who crave sun, sand, and surf, Shelter Island offers some fantastic beach-friendly accommodations. Here are three top picks that ensure guests enjoy the beach lifestyle during their stay.

Sunset Beach Hotel

• Why it's great for the ultimate beach vacation spot: Sunset Beach Hotel is an idyllic beachfront getaway, rated 9.2 by travelers. This hotel sets the stage for a perfect beach holiday with direct access to a sandy beach, beach umbrellas, and sun loungers for ultimate relaxation. Guests can also indulge in yoga classes held right on the beach or enjoy soothing massages available on the sand, making it a prime spot for wellness and leisure by the sea.
• Other amenities: In addition to its beach amenities, the hotel offers a range of conveniences like air conditioning, daily housekeeping, and luxurious Frette Italian sheets for a restful night’s sleep. Guests can also take advantage of the complimentary beach towels, a snack bar, and concierge services to enhance their stay. For those traveling with families, the hotel provides cribs and beach toys, ensuring that guests of all ages have a delightful experience.
• Nearby attractions: Crescent Beach - 0.15 miles, Sunset Beach - 0.02 miles, Shelter Island Whale's Tail - 1.91 miles